library / lib57f778e1e137089a
Assessing Change in Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy of Children and Adolescents (Psychology, Psychoanalysis & Psychotherapy)
In a sentence
An edited European collection that demonstrates how empirical research methods can be rigorously applied to evaluate process and outcome in psychoanalytic psychotherapy with children and adolescents without betraying the clinical complexity of the work.
At a moment when psychoanalytic psychotherapy for children and adolescents is being scrutinized by governments, insurers, and researchers, this EFPP volume answers the urgent question of whether and how change in such treatments can be assessed. Bringing together leading clinicians and researchers from Europe and the USA, it reviews systematic outcome studies, shows how a clinic can integrate research into its everyday culture, explains the role of treatment manuals, presents focused systematic case studies of 'turning points', reports the Heidelberg study of short- and long-term psychodynamic therapy, applies a psychoanalytic-neurobiological lens to AD/HD via the Frankfurt Prevention Study, maps researchable hypotheses about therapeutic process, and grounds it all in a careful treatment of research ethics with minors. The result is both a practical guide and a manifesto: the apparent paradox between the personal experience of therapy and the objectivity of empirical research is not only solvable but creatively fruitful.
The four lenses
- Science
- Statistics
- Systems
- Strategy
Tags
The model
A path model in which design levers (research integration, manuals, treatment intensity, therapist competence) and contextual conditions (clinical setting culture, parental involvement) shape psychological and behavioral states (therapeutic alliance, symbolic play, mentalization, emotion processing, work on focus) which in turn drive outcomes (symptom reduction, structural change, family functioning) in psychoanalytic psychotherapy with children and adolescents.
Integration of research activity into clinical settingdesign lever
The degree to which a clinically oriented psychotherapy institution systematically introduces and embeds research activity (data collection, force-field analysis, methodology seminars, leadership containment) into its everyday clinical and training culture.
Use of a treatment manualdesign lever
The provision and use of a written manual that brings together a rationale, focus, technique and management guidance for time-limited psychoanalytic work, supported by supervision and audiotape adherence monitoring, for trained clinicians.
Treatment intensity and lengthdesign lever
The frequency (e.g., once-weekly vs intensive multiple sessions) and duration (short-term vs long-term) of psychoanalytic psychotherapy, a dosage lever whose optimal value varies by disorder and developmental stage.
Therapist competence and trainingcontextual condition
The level of training, certification, clinical experience, personal therapy, supervision and capacity for flexible, attuned response that the therapist brings to the work, including ability to manage crises and use counter-transference.
Parental and family involvementcontextual condition
The extent to which work with parents and the family system is conducted in parallel with individual child therapy, including reclaiming parental projections and changing interaction patterns that maintain disorder.
Therapeutic alliance / emotional bondpsychological state
The quality of the affective bond and task collaboration between child and therapist, conceptualized as a secure-base attachment relationship that provides safety for exploration and active participation in therapy.
Symbolic/representational play engagementbehavioral pattern
The range, depth and emotional richness of the child's pretend, representational play and production of symbolic material, viewed as both a communicative medium and an agent of developmental change in therapy.
Interpretive and facilitative therapist activitybehavioral pattern
The accuracy, timing and relational dosing of therapist interpretations and facilitative interventions (description, mirroring, holding projections) that help the child reorganize understanding and sustain symbolic process.
Mentalization / reflective functionpsychological state
The child's developing capacity to interpret own and others' behavior in terms of internal mental states, which renders behavior meaningful and supports affect regulation and a coherent sense of self.
In-session emotion processing and regulationpsychological state
The depth of accessing, confronting and working through conscious and non-conscious emotions in session, supported by therapist attunement and mirroring, leading to improved emotion regulation structures.
Symptom reduction and improved functioningoutcome metric
Clinically significant and reliable reduction in psychic, social-communicative and somatic symptoms and improvement in global functioning across domains, the primary distal outcome of treatment.
Structural and developmental changeoutcome metric
Change beyond symptomatic improvement, including attachment security, ego-strength/flexibility, self-regulation, reflective capacity and developmental progress that may forestall future difficulties (e.g., the sleeper effect).
How they connect
- research integration in clinic → influences symptom reduction outcome
- treatment manual use → influences interpretive activity
- therapist competence → moderates therapeutic alliance
- therapeutic alliance → predicts symbolic play engagement
- symbolic play engagement → predicts mentalization reflective function
- interpretive activity → influences mentalization reflective function
- emotion processing → predicts structural and developmental change
- mentalization reflective function → mediates symptom reduction outcome
- treatment intensity and length → influences symptom reduction outcome
- parental and family involvement → moderates structural and developmental change
- therapeutic alliance → predicts symptom reduction outcome
- symptom reduction outcome → correlates structural and developmental change
The story
The reader A clinician, researcher, or institution practicing psychoanalytic psychotherapy with children and adolescents who wants to demonstrate that their work produces meaningful change.
External problem
Psychoanalytic child and adolescent treatments are being questioned by governments, insurers and researchers who demand evidence of efficacy.
Internal problem
Clinicians fear that quantitative measurement will threaten their clinical freedom, identity, and the irreducible complexity of individual therapy.
Philosophical problem
It is wrong to dismiss a long, rigorous clinical tradition as unscientific merely because it resists narrow evidence-based protocols.
The plan
- Survey existing process and outcome research to see what is already known about clinical applications.
- Prepare your clinical setting and staff to integrate research as a contained meeting of two cultures.
- Use manuals, focused systematic case studies, and validated instruments to structure and document the work.
- Identify and measure core change processes—alliance, mentalization, interpretation, play, emotion processing.
- Conduct the work within rigorous ethical safeguards for children and adolescents.
Success
- Your treatments are shown to be effective and defensible to funders and the public.
- Your clinical practice is enriched and your critical thinking deepened by research participation.
- Children and families benefit from better-targeted, evidence-informed psychoanalytic care.
At stake
- Psychoanalytic services for children remain unfunded and marginalized for lack of evidence.
- Practitioners remain isolated, defensive and unable to answer 'does this work and what makes it work?'
- Children are denied an effective treatment in favour of less appropriate interventions.
Chapter by chapter
ch01Child and adolescent psychotherapy research: Clinical applications
ch02Integrating research in a clinical setting for child psychotherapy: A case study about facilitating and hindering factors in psychoanalytic psychotherapy
ch03What does a manual contribute?
ch04Focused systematic case studies: An approach linking clinical work and research
ch05The Heidelberg study of psychodynamic psychotherapy for children and adolescents
ch06Attention-Deficit-Hyperactivity Disorder (AD/HD): A field for contemporary psychoanalysis?: Some clinical, conceptual and neurobiological considerations based on the Frankfurt Prevention Study
ch07Research on therapeutic processes: In psychodynamic psychotherapy with children and adolescents
ch08Ethical principles in conducting research with children and adolescents
Related in the literature
The measurement literature behind this signal — sourced, so you can defend it.
“Assessing Change in Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy of Children and Adolescents The EFPP Book Series Series Editors: Monica Lanyaao arid Didier Houzel Other Titles in the Series Chief Editor: John Tsiantis Counter-transference in Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy with Children and…”
— Assessingchangeinpsychoanalyticpsychothematch 76%
“of Education, University of Stockholm. Stockholm: Ericastiftelsen. Carlberg, G. (2009). Exploring change processes in psychodynamic child psychotherapy: The therapists' perspective. In: N. Midgley, J. Anderson, E. Grainger, T. Nesic-Vuckovic & C. Urwin (Eds.), Child…”
— Assessingchangeinpsychoanalyticpsychothematch 73%
“an extensive account of descriptive analysis of therapy process going back to Freud's story of "Little Hans" (Freud, 1909). Carlberg concludes by emphasizing that therapists have different ways of organizing their experiences of change processes. The important issue is whether…”
— Assessingchangeinpsychoanalyticpsychothematch 72%
Resources: Assessingchangeinpsychoanalyticpsychothe