library / lib914c3da8182bcc4d
Thinking Like Your Editor Rabiner
In a sentence
A veteran editor and agent reveals that the key to getting serious nonfiction published is to stop thinking like a writer and start thinking like an editor, focusing relentlessly on audience, commercial viability, and a strategic submission package.
In 'Thinking Like Your Editor,' publishing insider Susan Rabiner demystifies the commercial publishing world for authors of serious nonfiction, arguing that success hinges on a crucial shift in perspective. Instead of focusing solely on the writer's passion or the brilliance of an idea, aspiring authors must adopt an editor's mindset, relentlessly prioritizing the book's target audience and its market potential. This practical guide provides a step-by-step plan for crafting a winning submission package—the proposal, table of contents, and sample chapter—that answers the critical questions every publisher asks. Rabiner also shares invaluable lessons on the specific craft of serious nonfiction, from building a fair and compelling argument to employing narrative tension, ensuring that your important work not only gets published, but is published well.
The four lenses
- Science
- Statistics
- Systems
- Strategy
The model
This model, inferred from 'Thinking Like Your Editor,' proposes that successful publication of serious nonfiction is an outcome driven by an editor's enthusiasm for a project. This enthusiasm is generated by the project's perceived commercial viability and the author's credibility, both of which are a direct result of specific actions and conceptual frameworks adopted by the author, such as focusing on the audience and creating a strategic submission package. The entire process is moderated by the business realities of the publishing industry.
Audience-Centric Conceptualizationdesign lever
The author's process of defining the book's core idea, argument, and scope by first identifying a specific, reachable, book-buying audience and then tailoring the project to deliver clear value to that audience. This is the foundational 'thinking like an editor' mindset.
Strategic Submission Package Qualitydesign lever
The quality and effectiveness of the materials submitted to an agent or editor, specifically the proposal, table of contents, and sample chapter. A high-quality package clearly answers the 'Big Five' questions, demonstrates a compelling thesis, and showcases the book's structure and voice.
Mastery of Nonfiction Craftdesign lever
The author's demonstrated ability in the specific writing skills required for serious nonfiction, including the use of narrative tension to engage the reader and the construction of a scrupulously fair and well-reasoned argument.
Author Platform Developmentdesign lever
The author's established expertise, reputation, and visibility within the book's topic area. A strong platform is built through prior publications, media appearances, public speaking, and professional credentials, answering the 'Why you?' question for the publisher.
Perceived Commercial Viabilitypsychological state
An editor's assessment of a book project's potential for success in the marketplace. This judgment is based on the clarity of the target audience, the size of the potential market, the strength of the book's hook, and its fit within bookstore categories.
Perceived Author Credibilitypsychological state
An editor's belief in the author's competence, expertise, and trustworthiness to write a definitive, high-quality book on the proposed topic. It is a judgment about both the author's credentials and their demonstrated writing ability.
Editor Enthusiasmpsychological state
The acquiring editor's personal and professional excitement and commitment to a project. This enthusiasm is crucial as it motivates the editor to champion the book through the acquisition process and advocate for it within the publishing house.
Publishing Successoutcome metric
The multifaceted outcome of a successful author-publisher partnership, encompassing securing a favorable contract and advance, being published well (good editing, marketing, design), achieving strong sales, and reaching the intended audience.
Publishing Industry Realitiescontextual condition
The set of external business constraints and market forces that shape publishing decisions, including the dominance of chain bookstores, computerized inventory management, author sales tracks, and the high value placed on an author's media potential.
How they connect
- audience centric conceptualization → predicts project commercial viability
- strategic submission package → predicts project commercial viability
- mastery of nonfiction craft → predicts author credibility
- author platform development → predicts author credibility
- project commercial viability → predicts editor enthusiasm
- author credibility → predicts editor enthusiasm
- editor enthusiasm → predicts publishing success
- publishing industry realities → moderates publishing success
The story
The reader Aspiring or established authors of serious nonfiction (academics, journalists, experts) who have an important book they want to share with a wide audience via a traditional commercial publisher.
External problem
Their book proposals and manuscripts are consistently rejected by agents and publishers, or they receive offers that lead to a poor publishing experience.
Internal problem
They feel frustrated, confused, and disheartened by the opaque and seemingly arbitrary publishing industry, fearing their important work will never reach readers.
Philosophical problem
It is unjust that valuable ideas and well-written books are denied publication simply because talented authors don't understand the business-oriented 'rules of the game'.
The plan
- Adopt an editor's mindset by focusing on your book's specific, book-buying audience.
- Craft a strategic and comprehensive submission package (proposal, TOC, sample chapter) that demonstrates your book's commercial viability.
- Master the essential crafts of serious nonfiction writing, specifically fair argument and narrative tension.
- Navigate the publishing process, from finding an agent to partnering with the publisher on marketing and publicity.
Success
- The author secures a contract with an enthusiastic editor at a reputable publishing house for a significant advance.
- Their book is published well, with strong marketing and publicity support, leading to good reviews and sales.
- The author reaches their intended audience, makes a meaningful impact with their ideas, and establishes a successful, long-term writing career.
At stake
- The author continues to be rejected by the publishing industry, and their important manuscript languishes unread.
- They become disillusioned with writing and give up on their goal of being a published author.
- Their valuable knowledge and insights are never shared with the world.
Chapter by chapter
ch01Thinking Like an Editor: Audience, Audience, Audience
This chapter emphasizes the crucial role of understanding the audience in the editorial process, guiding writers to tailor their submissions effectively to meet specific reader needs and preferences.
ch03Wrapping Up the Submission Package: The Table of Contents, the Sample Chapter, and Supporting Materials
This chapter emphasizes the importance of a well-structured submission package for authors, focusing on how a comprehensive Table of Contents, a compelling sample chapter, and appropriate supporting materials can significantly influence a publisher's decision to accept a manuscript.
ch04Placing Your Manuscript with a Publisher: To Agent or Not to Agent, and Other Questions about the Publishing Acquisition Process
The chapter explores the crucial decision authors face regarding literary agents in the publishing process, weighing the potential benefits against the freedom of direct submissions.
ch05A Question of Fairness and Other Limits of Argument in Serious Nonfiction
This chapter interrogates the constraints of fairness in arguments presented in serious nonfiction, questioning how these limits shape the overall effectiveness of the discourse.
- Fairness in nonfiction writing is not merely an ethical obligation; it is a complex balancing act that can affect the clarity and impact of arguments.
- Strict adherence to fairness can dilute a persuasive message, possibly leaving audiences disoriented about the author's true stance.
- Writers must critically assess which viewpoints warrant representation in their narratives for effective argumentation.
- Engaging different perspectives requires an analytical approach that does not sacrifice the strength of the central argument.
ch07From Introduction to Epilogue: Writing Your Book Chapter by Chapter—and What to Do When You Get into Trouble
This chapter explores the essential process of writing a book one chapter at a time and provides strategies to navigate the inevitable challenges that arise during the writing journey.
ch08p01How to Be Published Well (part 1/2)
Understanding the publishing process is essential for serious nonfiction authors, as editors prioritize a book's marketability and audience engagement over merely its content quality.
ch08p02How to Be Published Well (part 2/2)
Navigating the intricacies of getting published extends beyond having strong credentials; it necessitates articulating a compelling central question that drives a book's narrative and resonates with editors and readers alike.
- A compelling central question can transform a dull proposal into an engaging narrative, catching the eye of editors.
- Personal connection to a topic adds depth and engages potential readers, establishing a narrative thread throughout the proposal.
- Respectful critique of existing literature can position your work as a valuable contribution to the ongoing conversation around your topic.
- Proposal packaging matters greatly; well-structured, narrative-driven submissions have a greater chance of attracting interest from publishers.
ch09A Question of Fairness and Other Limits of Argument in Serious Nonfiction
This chapter explores the critical role of effective argumentation in serious nonfiction writing, emphasizing the need for fairness and integrity in presenting competing interpretations, while cautioning against the pitfalls of advocacy that sacrifices credibility.
- Effective argumentation in serious nonfiction requires not just a stable thesis but the integration of diverse perspectives to enhance credibility.
- Authors must take responsibility for their reputation by crafting arguments that are intellectually robust and fair to competing interpretations.
- Placing research at the heart of the argument ensures that conclusions remain grounded in evidence rather than personal conviction alone.
- A meaningful argument should engage readers through a depth of understanding and transparent reasoning, fostering a trust that empowers the author as a credible guide.
ch10Using Narrative Tension
This chapter argues that effective serious nonfiction must engage readers through narrative tension, weaving story elements into factual writing to capture interest and maintain engagement.
- Engaging storytelling is crucial for drawing in readers, even in serious nonfiction genres where factual integrity is essential.
- Effective narrative techniques can maintain focus and clarity, reducing the tendency for authors to meander into tangential subjects.
- The 'mind story' is a valuable tool for uncovering the deeper themes of a work, allowing authors to weave human experiences into their arguments.
- Balancing narrative tension with factual accuracy is a skill that challenges authors but ultimately enriches their writing.
ch11From Introduction to Epilogue: Writing Your Book Chapter by Chapter—and What to Do When You Get into Trouble
This chapter delves into the intricacies of writing introductions and conclusions for books, emphasizing the importance of clarity and purpose in engaging readers while addressing common challenges authors face during the writing process.
ch12How to Be Published Well
After submitting your manuscript, understanding the intricacies of the publishing process, specifically the editorial review stage, is crucial to ensure your book is received well in the marketplace.
- Successful publishing starts with clear communication and respect for your editor's time.
- Patience is essential; editors often have multiple projects, making it important for authors to manage their expectations effectively.
- Being open to criticism and willing to make significant changes can drastically improve your manuscript’s chances of success.
- The nature of editing is collaborative; a good relationship with an editor can yield significant benefits for an author’s career.
Related in the library